What’s the nicest thing one can say about the California bullet-train project, which received $9.95 billion in taxpayer funds after the narrow passage of a 2008 ballot initiative but 18 years later has yet to lay a mile of track? That it’s not the worst public works debacle of all time.
That dishonor goes to the failed 1880s French effort to build a canal in Panama linking the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. While working on the project, 22,000 French workers died from malaria, yellow fever and construction accidents. The canal plan was only approved by lawmakers after a massive bribery scheme. When it was revealed, the scandal toppled the French government.
So the state bullet train will have to settle for being the biggest public works boondoggle in U.S. history. It has long since surpassed Boston’s Big Dig underground freeway tunnel project, which ended up costing $24 billion, eight times more than expected. But it was completed, at least, after 16 years.
Which brings us to the nightmare Gov
Which brings us to the nightmare Gov. Gavin Newsom has left for successor Xavier Becerra, who says he wants to “reform” the project. But how? In 2009, the estimated cost to build a statewide system that could get riders from San Francisco to Los Angeles in two hours and 40 minutes — a promise that’s written into state law — was $45 billion. Now it’s $126 billion, and it’s not a true statewide bullet train any more. Gov. Jerry Brown gave up on trying to build high-speed tracks in Silicon Valley and north of Los Angeles in 2012 because of intense local opposition. So much for the two hour and 40 minute guarantee given to voters.
So far, the state has spent about $15 billion on the project. Of late, lawmakers have been providing another $1 billion a year — and that’s the best the project’s remaining fans can hope for given the state’s broken budget. The only way lawmakers can comply with the California Constitution’s requirement that budgets be balanced is by using accounting tricks to hide the fact that the state spends more than it takes in year after year.
No, the project isn’t going to be funded by private investors, a fantasy that the state High-Speed Rail Authority has been peddling for years. The 2008 initiative specifically barred investors from receiving public subsidies if train operations lost money. A rail authority finding that this would make private investment extraordinarily unlikely was never released until after Proposition 1A was approved. It proved exactly right.
Why would Democratic lawmakers keep funding a project
So why would Democratic lawmakers keep funding a project in a way that ensures it won’t be finished until the 22nd century? Why not pull the plug and let the bridges andinder of state idiocy?
Because, as Politico recently reported, the project has created 16,000 union jobs since construction began in 2015. The union pressure to keep funding a debacle is why Newsom — who saw the project as a massive waste of money while lieutenant governor — changed his tune long ago.
This will only surprise you if you’ve woken up after sleeping for 30 years. It’s no way to run a government. But it’s very much the California way.
